Reupholstering Pontoon Seat Furniture vs. Buying New: Pros and Cons Explored

What are my options?

When it comes to updating the furniture on your pontoon boat, you may find yourself torn between two options: reupholstering the existing seats or buying completely new. Both choices have their merits and drawbacks, and in this blog post, we will delve into the pros and cons of each approach. Specifically, we will discuss the advantages of reupholstery, such as the freedom to select colors and patterns, and the use of high-quality materials. Conversely, we will also explore the benefits of buying new, including faster delivery times and the allure of brand-new seating, while acknowledging potential downsides like lower quality materials and limited options for color and texture.

A recent pontoon that I recovered; the client had a great time selecting the exact shades of purple and green for this one!

Pros of Reupholstering:

  1. Freedom of Choice: One of the most significant advantages of reupholstering pontoon seat furniture is the ability to choose specific colors and patterns. By customizing the upholstery, you can ensure that the new design aligns perfectly with your personal style and boat’s aesthetics. This level of customization can be immensely satisfying and can give your boat a unique look
  2. High-Quality Materials: Another compelling aspect of reupholstery is the opportunity to select high-quality materials. By investing in premium fabrics and foam, you can enhance the comfort and durability of your seating. The ability to handpick materials ensures that you can prioritize longevity and performance, providing long-term value for your investment and many summers worth of happy memories!

Cons of Reupholstering:

  1. Cost: The cost of reupholstering pontoon seat furniture can be a significant drawback. On average, the expense of reupholstering a complete boat interior ranges from $4,000 to $7,000. Depending on the complexity of the project, this cost may even exceed the price of purchasing new furniture. It is essential to consider the financial implications carefully before committing to reupholstery.
  2. Time: Due to the custom nature of marine upholstery, it is a large time investment. You will need to meet with your upholsterer 2-3 times for measurements, fabric selection, seat dropoff/pickup, etc. Also, most local upholstery shops are usually booked out 2-6 months depending on the time of year.

Pros of Buying New:

  1. Faster Delivery: When buying new pontoon seat furniture from the internet, one of the significant advantages is the relatively quick delivery time. Most reputable online sellers can ship the products within 4-5 weeks, allowing you to enjoy your updated seating arrangement promptly.
  2. Brand-New Seating: The allure of brand-new seating cannot be overstated. Buying new ensures that you receive furniture in pristine condition, free from wear and tear. This fresh, clean appearance can elevate the overall aesthetic of your boat, giving it a polished and appealing look.

Cons of Buying New:

  1. Quality Concerns: One potential downside of buying new furniture is the use of lower-quality materials. Some manufacturers may cut corners to offer lower-priced options, resulting in compromised durability and performance. Vinyl seating, for example, is prone to delamination and peeling over time, which can be disappointing and require early replacement. Once a low-quality vinyl begins to peel, there is no way to fix it or stop the degradation.
  2. Limited Color and Texture Evaluation: When purchasing pontoon seat furniture online, you are often restricted to viewing colors and textures through digital images or descriptions. This limitation makes it challenging to assess the exact appearance and tactile qualities of the materials before making a purchase. Consequently, there is a risk of the actual product not matching your expectations.


Reupholstering pontoon seat furniture and buying new each have their own set of pros and cons. Reupholstery offers the freedom to select specific colors and patterns, as well as the advantage of using high-quality materials. On the other hand, buying new provides the convenience of faster delivery and the appeal of brand-new seating, though there may be concerns about material quality and limited opportunities for color and texture evaluation.

Ultimately, the decision between reupholstering and buying new will depend on your budget, preferences, and priorities. It is crucial to weigh these factors carefully to ensure a satisfactory outcome for your pontoon boat’s seating needs. As a small business owner, I always want to ensure that my clients are 100% on board and happy with their decision; that’s what makes the magic happen!


  1. Itís difficult to find experienced people for this topic, but you seem like you know what youíre talking about! Thanks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *